It's a story that every American schoolchild knows well: Helen Keller, a young deafblind girl, is taught to understand the world and overcome her disabilities through the constant work of Anne Sullivan. At first, Helen is opposed to learning anything. But a miracle at a water pump opens her eyes (metaphorically) to the unseen universe. The story is so commonplace that it has become a cliche. However, Arthur Penn's The Miracle Worker transcends these to present the story in a way that feels fresh and original. There are three real reasons why this story works. The first two are Anne Bancroft as Anne Sullivan and Patty Duke as Anne Frank. Both had honed their performances through the crucible of the Broadway stage, perfecting them until they became second nature. The third reason why the film works is Arthur Penn's direction. The man knew that the heart of the story was the relationship between the two women, so he frequently stands back, rejects exploitative camera work and editing, and lets the two actresses ACT. The scene where the two of them battle over a meal is so authentic, so real that it almost transcends acting into an uncanny valley of reality. The film can be exhausting to watch. But ultimately, it is worth it.
8/10
One of the best movies of the 20th Century, in all ways. Penn's treatment did this marvelous play perfect justice. And you are so right -- it is exhausting, which shows the perfection of acting and the talent of the director in doing just what you said - step back and let it unfold. It's all worth it just for the scene at the pump -- it still gives me chills and tears. Great piece of writing, Nate.
ReplyDeleteYou know...in a weird way...it feels like Penn was channeling Cassavettes during this film in his acting direction. Like I said, the best part of this film was how Penn just sat back and let the two main actresses do their thing.
ReplyDeleteThis is a terrific film, probably because the story itself is quite valid and does well to drawer the watcher in. I remember the VERY first film by Nichols, WHO'S AFRAID and that was an intense experience when I got the film and watched it late one night. This film by Penn is a great one, you are probably right.
ReplyDeleteThank you very much, Stephen! It's funny...we seem to agree on just about everything!
ReplyDelete